Posted by Siggy
https://asexualagenda.wordpress.com/2026/01/27/journal-club-does-everyone-have-a-gender/
http://asexualagenda.wordpress.com/?p=13190

This month, the ace journal club discussed
“Does Everyone Have a Gender? Compulsory Gender, Gender Detachment, and Asexuality” by Canton Winer (2025). (https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/epdf/10.1177/23780231251339382, open access)
The journal club meets once a month on Discord, using text or voice as club members prefer. We discuss a variety of academic works in ace studies, ranging from gender studies to psychology. Don’t worry about journal access, we can provide access. If you’re interested, please e-mail me at asexualagenda@gmail.com for an invite.
Summary
This study explored 30 interviews of people who expressed some form of detachment from gender, and discussed the practicalities of ungendering.
Context
– We’ve previously discussed the preprint of this article. We hadn’t realized it was the same study until late. But the discussion participants weren’t the same, so we might get some different perspectives.
– Our criticisms of the preprint appear to have been addressed in this version.
Gender detachment
– Gender detachment is a concept named by Canton Winer, rather than being an organic self-identity term. It refers to “individually held notions that gender is irrelevant, unimportant, pointless, and/or overall not a helpful framework for understanding and defining the self.”
– Gender detachment bears some similarity to agender, although we remarked on some differences. Although people who are agender may have the intention of distancing themselves from any gender, “agender” has grammatical parallelism to gender identity terms, which may influence how it’s used and interpreted.
– In contrast “gender detachment” expresses a relationship to gender, in a way that does not parallel gender identity terms. Thus, it sidesteps the question of categorizing people as gender detached or not.
– We compared to the term “asexual resonance” which can be used to draw relationships between historical figures to asexuality, sidestepping the question of whether we should categorize them as asexual.
Methodology
– Many of the participants gave some other answer when asked about their gender. For instance, many said they were agender. But when asked for clarification, they said it didn’t feel quite correct.
– The author then prompted people with the idea of gender detachment and asked if they related to it. Many did.
– We remarked that people are not necessarily committed to their answers to survey questions, and that’s why asking the question in different ways produces different responses.
– The methodology of prompting people with the idea of gender detachment could be questioned, but we felt that this was something you couldn’t quite get at any other way.
Observations
– The 30 interviewees were taken from a larger study about asexuality. In the larger study, one third of participants were AMAB, where the 30 who expressed gender detachment were almost all AFAB. We asked, is this because AMAB people are less likely to experience gender detachment, or are they less likely to bring it up in these interviews?
– Many of the interviewees remarked on the relationship between gender and asexuality. Gender may be important in determining who is attracted to you, but not so much when not seeking a relationship. Interviewees said that when they started exploring asexuality, they were able to let go of some of the pressure around gender.
– The article discusses race both in the context of theoretical arguments, and the interviews. Scholars have argued that ungendering Black people has been a form of white supremacist violence, a tool to deny personhood. However the interviewees mostly discussed race in relation to a different trend: the hypersexualization of black women. This does not necessarily dispute the scholarly theories; hypersexualization may simply be more salient to these asexual participants.
https://asexualagenda.wordpress.com/2026/01/27/journal-club-does-everyone-have-a-gender/
http://asexualagenda.wordpress.com/?p=13190